When a product fails, the buyer's rights come from two places: what the company promised and what the law says every product must do. In US law, the first is an express warranty and the second is an implied warranty. A brand's warranty terms only control the first.
Express and implied warranties side by side
| Express warranty | Implied warranty | |
|---|---|---|
| Comes from | What the seller or manufacturer says or shows | The law, automatically |
| Form | Written terms, ads, labels, descriptions, samples, spoken promises | None needed |
| Main types | Written warranty, guarantees, specific claims | Merchantability; fitness for a particular purpose |
| Legal source | UCC § 2-313; Magnuson-Moss for written consumer warranties | UCC §§ 2-314 and 2-315 |
| Can it be excluded? | It's limited by its own terms | Only with conspicuous disclaimers, and not when a written warranty is given |
What an express warranty is
Any statement of fact or promise about the goods that's part of the basis of the deal creates an express warranty, even without the word "warranty". A two-year warranty card, a spec on the box ("waterproof to 50 m") and a sample shown in the store all count. For written warranties on consumer products, the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act adds rules: clear terms, and a "full" or "limited" label for products over $10.
What an implied warranty is
The implied warranty of merchantability means a product sold by a merchant must do what such products ordinarily do. The implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose applies when the seller knows the buyer needs the product for a specific use and the buyer relies on the seller's advice. Neither needs to be written down.
Disclaimers and limited warranties
Sellers can disclaim implied warranties under the UCC with clear, conspicuous wording like "as is". But a company that gives a written warranty, or sells a service contract within 90 days of the sale, can't disclaim them under Magnuson-Moss. With a limited warranty, it can only cap their length at the written warranty's duration. Some states don't allow "as is" sales of consumer goods at all.
In the EU and UK
EU law doesn't use "implied warranty", but the legal guarantee plays the same role: goods must conform to the contract and be fit for normal use, for at least two years, and the buyer can't waive it. In the UK, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 gives similar statutory rights. A brand's own warranty sits on top, as covered in warranty vs guarantee.
What it means for brands
- Write your warranty knowing the law adds to it. Your terms can't remove the implied or statutory rights.
- Watch what your marketing promises. Claims on the box and in ads can become express warranties.
- Keep records per unit. Purchase date, serial number and repairs decide which warranty applies and for how long.
Official sources
Frequently asked questions
What is an example of an express warranty?
A manufacturer's "2-year limited warranty against defects in materials and workmanship" is one. So is a salesperson saying a jacket is waterproof, or a product description stating a battery lasts 10 hours, when it's part of the basis of the sale.
What is an example of an implied warranty?
A toaster that doesn't toast breaches the implied warranty of merchantability, even if the seller never promised anything. If a store recommends specific boots for ice climbing after you explained your plans and they fail at it, that breaches the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.
Can a company disclaim implied warranties?
Under the UCC, a seller can disclaim them with conspicuous wording such as "as is". But under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, a company that gives a written warranty or sells a service contract within 90 days can't disclaim them, only limit their length in a limited warranty. Several states also bar "as is" sales of consumer goods.
How long does an implied warranty last?
State law sets it, through the statute of limitations, which is usually four years from delivery under the UCC. A limited written warranty may cap the implied warranties at its own duration, if that's reasonable and stated clearly.
Does the EU have implied warranties?
Not under that name. The EU's legal guarantee of conformity does the same job: goods bought from a business must match the contract and be fit for normal use, for at least two years, and it can't be signed away.
