UL and ETL marks look like competing standards, but they're competing labs. Both are Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratories (NRTLs) approved by OSHA, and both test products against the same safety standards. A lamp with an ETL mark and one with a UL mark have proven the same thing.
UL and ETL side by side
| UL | ETL | |
|---|---|---|
| Lab | UL Solutions | Intertek |
| Recognized by OSHA as an NRTL | Yes | Yes |
| Standards tested to | Applicable US and Canadian standards, many written by UL | The same standards |
| Factory follow-up | Regular inspections | Regular inspections |
| Accepted by inspectors and retailers | Yes | Yes |
| Public database | UL Product iQ | Intertek's online directory |
UL Listed, Recognized and Certified
- UL Listed: a finished, standalone product, like a lamp or a charger, has been tested to the safety standard.
- UL Recognized: a component or material, like a power supply or wire, has been evaluated for use inside another product. It's shown with a backwards "RU" mark, and the finished product still needs its own listing.
- UL Certified: UL Solutions' newer mark designs use the general word "Certified", and a "Smart" version adds a QR code linking to the certification record. Check UL Product iQ to see what a mark covers.
- ETL Listed: Intertek's equivalent of a listing for a finished product.
Is either one required?
No general federal law requires UL or ETL for consumer products. In practice, most electrical products need one: OSHA requires NRTL approval for many products used at work, electrical codes require listed equipment in installations, and big retailers and insurers require it from suppliers. Any OSHA-recognized NRTL's mark counts, which also includes labs like CSA.
UL and ETL vs CE
UL and ETL are lab certifications for North America. The EU's CE marking is a legal declaration by the manufacturer that the product meets EU law, and usually involves no lab at all for consumer electronics. Radio devices in the US also need FCC authorization. See CE vs FCC vs UL.
How to choose
- Check what your retailers and markets accept. Almost all accept any NRTL mark.
- Compare lead times and cost between labs for your product category.
- Keep the certificate and file number with the product record, and check the listing stays active after design changes.
Official sources
Frequently asked questions
Is ETL as good as UL?
For proving safety in the US and Canada, yes. Both UL Solutions and Intertek are OSHA-recognized Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratories, and both test to the same standards. Inspectors, OSHA and retailers accept either mark.
Why would a brand choose ETL over UL?
Usually speed, price or an existing relationship with the lab. Since both certify to the same standards, brands often pick the lab that can test sooner or that already tests their other products.
What is the difference between UL Listed and UL Recognized?
UL Listed means a complete product was tested and can be used on its own. UL Recognized means a component, such as a power supply or switch, was evaluated for use inside another product. A product built from recognized components still needs its own listing.
What is the difference between UL Listed and UL Certified?
UL Solutions has been moving its marks to newer designs that use the general word 'Certified', including a 'Smart' version with a QR code that links to the certification record. To know what was actually certified, check the product in UL Product iQ, UL's public database.
Is UL or ETL certification required by law?
There's no general federal requirement for consumer products. OSHA requires NRTL approval for many products used in workplaces, local electrical codes require listed equipment in installations, and most large retailers require a listing from their suppliers.
Does UL or ETL replace CE marking in Europe?
No. UL and ETL are for the US and Canadian markets. In the EU, the manufacturer must meet EU law and affix the CE marking, which is a legal declaration, not a lab mark.
